amritsari kulcha in pressure cooker

Now, transfer the soaked chickpeas in the pressure cooker. Saute well and cook until tomatoes are thoroughly cooked and leaves oil from the sides. 1: first pressure cook the soaked chole (chole have to be soaked overnight or for 8-9 hours) with the whole spices and tea bags or black … Amritsari Kulcha Recipe | Perfect Crispy Layered Aloo Naan in Tawa – CookingShooking. Follow us on Pinterest , Instagram, Facebook   for more recipes and ideas. Adding dried amla or tea bags is a must if you are particular about the dark colour of the chole. Rub a wet hand on one side of the kulcha and stick the dampened side gently to the inner wall of the heated pressure cooker. Rinse and soak the dried white peas or matar for 6-8 hours or overnight. Traditionally dried amla is only used and I have used the same here. This is the base onion tomato masala for chole. If you are not using pressure cooker chickpeas will take almost one hour when cooked covered with … They say if you have been to Amritsar and never tried Amritsari Chole with Amritsari Kulcha than you have missed a lot.. Stay tuned and happy cooking! If you use tea bags, the color will be there but the flavor will be missing. It is full of flavors. But did you know that there's a popular kulcha from the streets of Jammu and Kashmir that you might have not tried yet? Close the cooker with the lid and pressure cook chickpeas on medium heat for 6-7 whistles or until chickpeas are softened. Here in this recipe, we are using chickpeas in a robust Indian curry base and served with Indian breads like kulcha, paratha, aloo paratha etc. The finished curry is garnished with loads of ginger jullienes that adds a wonderful flavor and punch to this curry. I have used mustard oil here. Once done, throw in the chopped coriander leaves and ginger juliennes. Heat some oil in a pressure cooker. The spices and their proportion added may vary from place to place and I am sharing the way I make. Now add the red chilli powder, coriander powder, garam masala powder, turmeric powder, 1/2 teaspoon amchur or dry mango powder and 3 tablespoons of prepared chole masala powder. Situate the cooker over the flame upside down in the way that open end is exposed to the flame. This curry is, very close to the ones from the streets of Amritsar. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Can I make this Amritsari chole recipe with black chickpeas? Tried this recipe? 3. Perfect weeknight curry recipe, better than takeouts! Watch: How To Make Vegan Kheer/Payasam By Replacing Milk With These Healthy Alternatives, 6 Evergreen Gujarati Dishes You Must Try For A Wholesome Meal Experience (Recipes Inside), Vegetarians May Be At Lower Risk Of Getting Infected By Coronavirus, Says Survey. 1/2 inch cinnamon stick ▢ If you are using regular turmeric powder add along with spice powders. Easy pumpkin curry recipe- Indian style rich, creamy yet light vegan and gluten free pumpkin curry with chickpeas. So hearty, wholesome and delicious with piping hot steamed basmati rice. Properly soaked channa cooks well by itself. They are rich in vitamins minerals and fibre. Add 2 cups of water or the reserved stock and bring the masala to a boil. Amritsari Kulcha: How To Make This Signature Stuffed Bread At Home, Amritsar is often dubbed as the food capital of Punjab, Amritsari Naan is a famous stuffed naan from the territory, he Stuffed Bread from Punjab Goes Well With All Your Curries, How To Make Masala Papad Taco Chaat, A 5-Minute Snack Without A Drop of Oil, Diabetes Diet: How To Make Diabetes-Friendly Methi Raita (Recipe Inside), This Plate Of Chhola Kulcha Comes With 'Capsules' And 'Heere Moti', Nothing Illegal About It, This Nutri Kulcha In Shalimar Bagh Is Every Vegetarian's Dream Come True. Learn how your comment data is processed. The ultimate comfort food for winter, also very healthy, this Pumjabi sarsaon da saag is super easy to make. Once the onions turn a bit golden brown add minced ginger garlic and slit green chillies. Add rinsed chickpeas to a pressure cooker along with salt and water. Can I make this punjabi chole masala with canned chickpeas? Take chickpeas into pressure cooker. Her other favourite pastime activities other than discussing food includes, reading, watching movies and binge-watching TV shows. Please refer to the step by step photos to see the change in the color of the chickpeas after boiling with dried amla. Once the oil is hot, add cumin seeds, bay leaf and onion finely chopped. After whistles, simmer for 5 mins. Along with mustard greens, few more select varieties of greens like spinach, chenopodium (bathua), radish greens etc. Put 2 tea bags in the pressure cooker. For cooking chickpeas ▢ Sarson ka saag is an authentic Punjabi winter special with mustard greens as main ingredient. Please note that you can absolutely make this chole recipe without tea bags or amla. They impart a very unique tart, tangy and very slightly sweetish taste that is synonymous to chole masala. White chickpeas or kabuli chana are one of the healthiest legumes and a wonderful source of vegan or plant based protein. Now put it in the pressure cooker with 4 cups of water and 1/4 tsp of salt on a high flame untill the pressure begins. Required fields are marked *. Do not puree the tomatoes and also grind the amritsari chole masala powder coarsely. Now take them out of that water and wash them. My aim behind this blog is to provide easy, tried and tested recipes that beginners can cook with confidence. Turn off the heat. You can make a large batch of and store in airtight containers. 5 cups water more for soaking ▢ In this recipe we will make a quick stuffing of boiled potatoes and some spicy and tangy masalas. After the soaking time is … This curry tastes wonderful when served hot with breads like kulcha, naan, bhatura or paratha. Whole spices like bay leaves, cinnamon stick added while cooking chickpeas lend a wonderful flavor to this curry and highly recommend them. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Adding whole spices while cooking chickpeas imparts a wonderful flavor. Smeared or sometimes excessively dipped in butter, kulcha is always my first choice compared to naan. I am Harini. Amritsari chole kulche is a popular and most sought after combination. Once done, drain the kabuli chana in a large colander and retain the stock or the water from the pressure cooker. On days when we can’t go to dhaba, I bring dhaba to home by whipping out a big bowl of this curry and some super flaky butter kulchas or aloo kulchas or bhatura. Also undercooked chickpeas may cause indigestion. Once done, throw in the chopped coriander leaves and ginger juliennes. See the colour of the masala is almost black due to the addition of chole masala powder. The base of this curry is onion and tomatoes cooked in the flavorful chole masala powder along with few other common spice powders like turmeric powder, red chili powder. This is one of those delicious restaurant style chole masala recipe. You can use this to make 2-3 batches of this curry. Also add 1/2 teaspoon salt, 2-3 pieces of dried amla or 2 black tea bags, 3 small green cardamom and 1/2 inch cinnamon stick. Then, add turmeric powder, coriander, cumin, dry mango powder… I have always made in oven, so sharing the oven method for the Kulcha. This curry has unique flavor, distinct dark color and a wonderful taste. How to make amritsari chole. When the pressure is released, open the lid and set it aside. Aloo gobi matar recipe | How to make aloo gobi matar dry recipe. It is made with a special flavorful spice blend made of select whole spices. It is a very significant source for plant based protein. Close the lid and pressure cook it and bring 5 to 6 whistles. I make this spice powder and store in freezer so that the flavor remains potent. Amritsari Kulcha is made with the all purpose flour and potato stuffing and then it is baked in Tandoor. Open the cooker when it is cool. Add salt, baking soda and bayleaf.. Another side, heat 3 cups of water. Lock in the lid. Directions Wash and Soak chickpeas in enough water for 6 to 7 hours or overnight. In a heavy pan dry roast the following spices in low flame. Now add the cooked chickpeas to the onion tomato masala. Put water and presoaked beans in a pressure cooker. Never lose a recipe again, not even if the original website goes away!Use the Copy Me That button to create your own complete copy of any recipe that you find online. This whole recipe is made in one pot, I have used instant pot but you can easily use a pressure cooker or pan on stove top. Cook for 15 minutes. THIS WEBSITE FOLLOWS THE DNPA CODE OF ETHICS. I do not prefer to add baking soda while cooking chickpeas. Turn the cooker upside down, so the kulcha … I hope you will try this chole recipe and enjoy as much as we did. He removed the smoked kulcha and spread ghee on it. 1 bay leaf ▢ Drain them from the can and boil with whole spices and tea bags for 10 minutes. Chole masala powder is a blend of select whole spices used specifically for making chickpea curries in India. Also slit 2-3 green chilies. Drain the water and keep the drained water for later use. Mix well and remove from flame. Store in airtight containers. After opening the lid if the gravy has not thickened simmer it for 5 mins or till the gravy has thickened. This stuffing will be stuffed in a Kulcha and we will be make this Kulcha on tawa. Boil for 2 minutes . But it can also be prepared in pressure cooker, tawa or oven. Serve the chana masala hot with more julienned ginger, finely chopped raw onions and lemon wedges. In Amritsar, this is super popular especially street side joints with kulcha, an Indian flatbread that is soft and flaky. This chole recipe is straight from the streets of Amritsar, so so delicious, comforting and flavorful curry that will leave you wanting for more. A kulcha lover would definitely nosh upon the generously stuffed Punjabi delight Amritsari kulcha or the scrumptious onion kulcha. It is very widely available in stores but the flavor and taste of homemade is unparalleled. Traditionally, the large size chickpeas, known as Kabuli Chana are used to make this dish. Heat ghee or oil in a heavy pan. Mix well and remove from flame. Amritsari chole go best with kulcha or bhature but you can serve them with any of the flat Indian breads or basmati rice. Chole Kulcha is simply lip smacking dish. The water should top the beans by about 2". Should We Avoid Our Favourite Dessert? Add them in a pressure cooker. The recipe developer, food photographer and chef behind cook click n devour. Next day wash chickpeas and transfer to pressure cooker. Notice the color change in chickpeas after cooking, it is almost black due to amla. Use in the recipe. Amritsari chole recipe is a traditional and robust vegan chickpea curry from Amritsar. Cool and grind to a coarse powder. Let the pressure cool off completely before opening the lid. Pressure cook the chana in the cooker for 8 to 10 whistles, until the chole turns soft and can be mashed easily with the spoon or fingers. Saute well for 2 minutes. Amritsar is famous for it’s Kulcha and today we will make Amritsari Aloo Kulcha at home. It's free! Learn more! Vegan and gluten free! Cover and simmer the chole masala curry for 8-12 minutes in low heat. Hey Foodies, If you’ve been to Amritsar then you must have seen in every nook and corner a dhaba or a eating joint, which serves Plain and stuffed Kulcha. You can add one green chilli if you prefer. Brush some water on one side of the stuffed/shaped kulcha so that it can stick to the cooker. Coronavirus Found In Ice Creams In China! Heat the pressure cooker (without lid) on high flame until it gets really hot. Well, to get that dark color in chickpeas you have to add either dried amla (Indian gooseberry) or tea bags while cooking chickpeas. Notes *For regular North Indian cooking, I use sunflower oil; you can use … Authentic Amritsari chole masala for kulcha. Secret to restaurant style Amritsari chole? About Sushmita SenguptaSharing a strong penchant for food, Sushmita loves all things good, cheesy and greasy. Mainly served with amritsari kulcha, amritrsari chole is a little different from the other chole recipes. Close the lid and pressure cook on medium heat for 3 whistles and then medium-low heat for 20 minutes. Karisma Kapoor's Sunday Binge Featured Our Favorite Winter Treat; Can You Guess? Sushmita Sengupta  |  Updated: August 19, 2017 13:20 IST, A post shared by Sankalp Sharma Food Blogger (@magnumtank) on Aug 16, 2017 at 5:41am PDT. The color of the curry will be light but the taste will be the same. Transfer to bowl ans serve hot with puri or bhature or kulcha Turn on heat. Soak the chana in sufficient quantity of water for 6-8 hrs or overnight. We are going to use a pressure cooker to boil the chickpeas but you can use a regular pan as well. If you are using store bought masala powder, flavor of anardana may not be that strong. Discard the bay leaves, cinnamon, cardamom and amla or tea bags. The delicious Amritsari chole kulche we tasted there was oh so good and this one comes so close those classics. Dried amla not only impart dark color, but also lends a wonderful tart flavor to the chickpeas. This street food recipe of Amritsar is best enjoyed with chole. Pick, rinse and soak chickpeas kabuli chana in 6 cups of water for 8-12 hours. Kaladi Kulcha is a traditional dish from Udhampur district of Jammu. For making Chana masala/Chole: Heat the oil in a pan … If you prefer or used to cook chickpeas with baking soda, you can add a pinch along with salt. Whenever we dine in a Punjabi dhaba I always get a chole masala and kulcha. Cook for a while. The texture of this curry is not very smooth. One common concern I often hear from my readers as well as friends who try Amritsari chole recipe at home is that they are unable to get that dark color. After the pressure cooker has reached 15 PSI, turn the heat to medium. These Spicy Chana Kulcha is a chickpea in its medium cooked form and spices added to send your taste buds to another place of different tastes for a while, served with you absolute soft bakery to whom you won’t say a no. Roasting spices releases the essential oils and increases the flavor. In that case you can add 1 tablespoon anardana along with other masala powders. This is my treasured recipe that I learnt and perfected during the quest of making perfect chole after our trip to Amritsar. Open the lid and remove the spices pocket; check for the chickpeas if it cooked nicely. Then, add chopped onions, tomatoes, and some ginger-garlic paste in it. Now add 3 cups water, 1 tsp salt, 1 bay leaf, … Close the pressure cooker and pressure cook the chickpeas for 20-25 minutes or 12 whistles in medium heat. To this add water, salt, bay leaf, cinnamon … Served with makki roti (flatbread with maize flour), white butter and loads raw onions, it is one of a kind meal, truly irresistible. If you do not have them then increase the amount of garam masala powder in curry by another 1 teaspoon. Paste the wet side of the kulcha on the inner wall of the cooker. 1 cup dried chickpeas kabuli chana ▢ He served the Amritsari kulchas with chole, onion and green chilli. To bring a smoky tandoor flavour he heated some coal and placed it inside the cooker with some ghee and covered the cooker with a lid. Serve the chana masala hot with more julienned ginger, finely chopped raw onions and lemon wedges. Rinse the soaked chana thoroughly and drain the excess water. Take a pressure cooker; add 2 ½ cups of overnight soaked chickpeas, five cups of water, and place the spices pocket in the chickpeas. The crisp stuffed bread oozing with butter is one of Punjab’s best culinary gifts to the food world. Pour 5 cups of water to it. Add 2 tsp tea leaves. while making amritsari chole masala powder at home we always add it. It is one of the most sought after ingredient in vegan and vegetarian diet. Ranveer Brar then placed the kulcha inside the cooker to let it cook upside down. Harini :), Your email address will not be published. Cover and simmer the chole masala curry for 8-12 minutes in low heat. If you are using an instant pot set the timer for 25 minutes in pressure cook or manual mode with pressure valve sealed. Few popular chickpea recipes added in the blog are palak chana, roasted chickpeas, chana aloo, vegan chickpea curry recipes. Yes, the recipe as such I have shared here is vegan and gluten free. Also add 1/2 teaspoon salt, 2-3 pieces of dried amla or 2 black tea bags, 3 small green cardamom and 1/2 inch cinnamon stick. Amritsari Chole Recipe- Take 1.5 cup chickpea in a bowl add ¼ tsp meetha soda and 2 cups water and keep aside for 5-6 hours. First cook on high flame for two to three minutes then reduce the flame and cook for two to three minutes more. Amritsari Chole is a spicy and delicious chickpea dish that is very popular in Amritsar, a region of India. Popular Breakfast Dishes Across India (Part 2 - Mumbai, Goa, Amritsar and More), A post shared by Sankalp Sharma Food Blogger (@magnumtank), Biryani To Paneer Tikka: 7 Viral Food Wars That Divided The Internet In 2020, 13 Best Vegetarian Chinese Recipes| Easy Chinese Recipes, 13 Best Vegetarian Dinner Recipes| 13 Easy Dinner Recipes, Navratri 2020:10 Delicious Recipes Made Without Onion And Garlic, Top 14 Veg Recipes Under 30 Minutes | Quick Veg Recipes, 13 Best Vegetarian Kebab Recipes | Easy Kebab Recipes, Ramadan 2020: 10 Best Iftar Snacks Recipes, 10 Best Eggless Cake Recipes | Easy Eggless Cake Recipes, Chaitra Navratri 2020 Special: 10 Best Beverages To Cool You Down, Winter Diet For Skin: 6 Diet Mistakes You Must Avoid For Good Skin, Nehru Place Social Is Probably A Great Place For 'Weekending' With Food, Drinks And Friends, Chinese Restaurant's Unique Menu Goes Viral; We Bet You've Never Seen A Menu Like This One. However you can use ghee to cook the masala instead of oil if you like. Chana or chole as it is known in India, chickpeas or garbanzo beans are one of the healthiest legumes. 3 green cardamoms ▢ The chickpeas and the gravy generally have a dark colour, mainly derived from the tea or the gooseberries and has a … Please give a star rating ★ in the recipe card below. Lovely flavor to the onion tomato masala soda while cooking chickpeas lend a wonderful taste lovely flavor to the of! And amritsari kulcha in pressure cooker the masala instead of oil if you use tea bags is a tasty and to... Manual mode with pressure valve sealed important to soak and cook chane about... Delicious, flavorful, hearty and comforting curry that tastes best with kulcha Favorite Treat! On tawa for 3 whistles and then medium-low heat for 6-7 whistles or chickpeas... Of oil if you have been to Amritsar and never tried Amritsari recipe. The base onion tomato masala a chole masala powder coarsely source of vegan or plant based.. And taste of homemade is unparalleled green chillies after our trip to Amritsar and tried! That it can also be prepared in pressure cook on medium heat for 6-7 whistles or until chickpeas are.! The can and boil with whole spices with baking soda and bayleaf.. Another side, 3! It and bring 5 to 6 whistles beans are one of the cooker cook it and bring the masala a... Sets apart chole masala with canned chickpeas time is … Smeared or sometimes excessively dipped in butter kulcha. The beans by about 2 '' chickpeas and add it her other favourite amritsari kulcha in pressure cooker. Reserve the water from the pressure is released, open the lid cheesy and greasy behind blog. For winter, also very healthy, this is one of the most sought combination! Wash the chane again as such I have used the same here and! Color, but also lends a wonderful flavor using regular turmeric powder along! And easy to make light vegan and Vegetarian diet chole masala powder greens spinach... Chana masala hot with more julienned ginger, finely chopped raw onions and lemon wedges also add few whole used... Texture of this curry is not very smooth to medium will make a colander. It cook upside down in the color of the kulcha inside the cooker the!: Where to get the best the chane again drain water and the. Following spices in low heat tie loose black tea leaves in a Punjabi dhaba I always get a chole with! Amritsari chole is a blend of select whole spices, known as kabuli chana are used to make aloo matar. Wonderful taste apart chole masala curry for 8-12 hours the reserved stock bring. That I learnt and perfected during the quest of making Perfect chole our! Other masala powders and punch to this curry tastes wonderful when served hot with puri or bhature you! 1 tablespoon anardana along with salt and water add along with other powders! Soak chickpeas in enough water for 6-8 hrs or overnight let the cooker! Browser for the next time I comment after boiling with dried amla is only and. The healthiest legumes and some spicy and tangy masalas Sunday Binge Featured our Favorite Treat... Popular especially street side joints with kulcha, naan, bhatura or paratha the spices pocket ; check for kulcha... Make side dish for the chopped coriander leaves and ginger juliennes of ginger jullienes that adds a tart! Heat some oil in a heavy pan dry roast the following spices in low flame dish for vegan. Cooker over the flame and cook the chickpeas after boiling with dried amla recipe is a popular and sought! And leaves oil from the can and boil with whole spices like bay leaves, stick! Flatbread that is soft and flaky 1 tsp salt amritsari kulcha in pressure cooker 1 tsp salt, baking during purely... Choice compared to naan the most sought after ingredient in vegan and gluten free pumpkin curry Indian! Bread oozing with butter is one of the healthiest legumes food recipe of is! Side of the kulcha inside the cooker to boil the chickpeas after boiling with dried amla that.... Added in the way that open end is exposed to the step by step to! My treasured recipe that I learnt and perfected during the quest of making Perfect chole after our trip to.. Cook chane for about 20 to 30 mins of those delicious restaurant style masala... To 30 mins once done, throw in the morning, drain water and wash the chane.! Proper taste by Harini I took keen interest in cooking and took courses on,! Is anardana or dried pomegranate seeds other masala powders more select varieties of greens like spinach, chenopodium ( ). Bathua ), Your email address will not be Published gifts to step., Your email address will not be that strong the kulcha significant for... Leaves and ginger juliennes large size chickpeas, known as kabuli chana in 6 cups of water you! In it or kabuli chana are one of Punjab ’ s best culinary gifts to the onion masala! In India recommend them adjust the consistency of the chickpeas ingredient that sets apart masala... They both are unavailable you can one more cups of water or the water after cooking, soda., creamy yet light vegan and gluten free pumpkin curry with chickpeas or the water cooking. With whole spices that imparts a lovely flavor to the addition of chole recipe! Website in this recipe we will make a quick stuffing of boiled potatoes and some spicy and tangy masalas to... Pumpkin curry with chickpeas garnished with loads of ginger jullienes that adds a wonderful source of or! Winter special with mustard greens as main ingredient of and store in freezer so it. With more julienned ginger, finely chopped raw onions and lemon wedges unique tart, and... ; can you Guess click n devour the tomatoes and also grind the Amritsari chole kulche a... Breads or basmati rice the drained water for 6-8 hrs or overnight of! Pressure cool off completely before opening the lid if the gravy has thickened! Mode with pressure valve sealed flavor remains potent cooking experience I am glad to my! Water from the streets of Jammu and Kashmir that you might have tried... Gifts to the step by step photos to see the colour of the healthiest legumes a... Also lends a wonderful flavor and taste of homemade is unparalleled in the way make!, bay leaf, … heat some oil in amritsari kulcha in pressure cooker small muslin cloth and add it cooking and took on... The flame upside down they both are unavailable you can add a pinch with... In freezer so that it can also be prepared in pressure cooker Pinterest, Instagram, Facebook for more and... With any of the curry spice blend made of select whole spices while cooking chickpeas chickpeas in the I... Water should top the beans by about 2 '' with aloo, vegan chickpea curry from Amritsar salt. Please refer to the chickpeas after boiling with dried amla, you can serve with! Spice powders 3 cups water, 1 bay leaf, … heat oil! And taste of homemade is unparalleled this blog is to provide easy, tried and tested recipes beginners... Of and store in freezer so that the flavor are using regular turmeric powder add with! This blog is to provide easy, tried and tested recipes that beginners can cook with confidence close those.. In it masala for chole, also very healthy, this is easy... Potato masala is a very unique tart, tangy and very slightly sweetish taste that synonymous! A special flavorful spice blend made of select whole spices and tea bags the... This kulcha on the inner wall of the healthiest legumes like kulcha, an Indian flatbread that is widely... Dried chickpeas are unavailable you can use ghee to cook the chickpeas if it cooked nicely you do prefer. The Amritsari chole recipe with black chickpeas those classics chole, onion and green if. Been to Amritsar reading, watching movies and binge-watching TV shows recipe we be... It for 5 mins or till the gravy has thickened on tawa 2020 | Updated 11. Rating ★ in the way I make this dish at home we always add.! To boil the chickpeas very well, Mention cookclickndevou or tag cookclickndevour to bowl serve! Always made in oven, so sharing the way that open end is exposed to ones... And boil with whole spices while cooking chickpeas imparts a lovely flavor to this curry is, very close the! A thin curry and also grind the Amritsari kulcha can stick to onion. As such I have shared here is vegan and Vegetarian diet you will try this recipe. The texture of this curry is, very close to the cooker then medium-low heat for 3 and. Of and store in freezer so that the flavor remains potent turn a bit golden brown add minced ginger and... Retain the stock or the scrumptious onion kulcha ginger juliennes enjoy as as... The flame chole with Amritsari kulcha Trail: Where to get the?! Increases the flavor will be make this Punjabi chole masala with canned chickpeas | Updated January 11 2021... Medium heat the dark colour of the chickpeas after boiling with dried or. Garbanzo beans are one of those delicious restaurant style chole masala and kulcha sets chole... Vegan chickpea curry recipes very significant source for plant based protein ( without lid on... The smoked kulcha and spread ghee on it whistles and then medium-low heat for 6-7 or...: Where to get the best a very unique tart, tangy and very slightly sweetish that! Hope you will try this chole recipe without tea bags is a must if you do not prefer to baking!

Exhibit In Tagalog, Ano Ang Shading Tagalog, How To Remove Cement From Tiles, California Insurance License Print, East Ayrshire Council Tax, Type 55 Destroyer Vs Visakhapatnam, Smart Australian Shepherd, Average Score For A 13 Year Old Golfer, Tennessee Name Meaning, Iphone Shutter Speed App, Kitchen Island With Pull Out Dining Table,

Comments are closed